Public input is the most critical element to running an responsive, effective local government. I strongly encourage the public to attend City Council meetings and participate. In fact, in a time of dwindling resources (i.e. right now) it is critical that we receive feedback on which city expenditures are most important to our citizens.
There is no doubt in my mind that the City Council and City staff are intent on making sure we are spending our resources as effectively as possible. The challenge we often face is properly communicating to the public WHY an expenditure of dollars is in the best interest of our citizens. I'm hoping that this blog can contribute to the effort and I've encouraged every member of our staff to do a better job of communicating with the public.
Misinformation is the biggest challenge we face when attempting to explain our actions to the public. The public comment phase of our City Council meeting is an excellent venue for hearing the general concerns of the public. Unfortunately, it often becomes a platform for critics of city government to make false statements in order to justify their point of view. In the past, most cities have ignored these comments and just assumed that the general public realizes that these accusations are so extreme, that they must be false.
Unfortunately, experience has taught us that our silence in these situations often convinces the public that these accusations must be true. Therefore, I've decided that when appropriate, it is my responsibility to set the record straight when comments are factually inaccurate. That is why I responded several times at last night's meeting.
Here are some of the inaccuracies stated at the podium last night:
Statement: "Manteca has the highest sales tax rate in state...and the nation".
Answer: Actually, Manteca's 9.25% isn't even close to the highest rate in the state. Both South Gate and Pico Rivera have 10.25% rates, and Pico Rivera will rise to 10.75% in July as noted in an article you can access
here. It is also important to note that most of the Sales Tax goes to the State or County, Manteca only gets 1.5%--and that extra half percent was approved by a 2/3 vote of the public. If the speaker wants some really high sales tax rates, she should go to
this link where it shows that Tennessee has an AVERAGE sales tax rate of 9.36%!
Statement: "In 2007 the majority of the City's property tax went to the Redevelopment Agency instead of to the General Fund to pay for services."
Answer: When a citizen pays their property tax, only 11-15% of their tax comes back to the City. Most of it goes to the State, the Schools and the County. As I noted in a previous post, in a Redevelopment Area, the Agency receives 80-100 percent of the incremental increase in taxes after the project area is adopted. Therefore, the Agency doesn't take dollars away from the City, it provides a windfall of taxes that the City normally would never receive. In Manteca's case, well over $100 million has been reinvested in the community that would normally go to agencies outside the City.
Statement: The City is going to eminent domain a number of properties for a 560-unit subdivision.
Answer: The Machado Estates subdivision would include the ANNEXATION of a number of properties currently outside the City boundaries. The City would not be acquiring these properties, they would now be inside the City limits.
Here is an article in the Bulletin that talks about the development.
Labels: City Council