City Manager's Blog

Steve Pinkerton has been the City Manager of Manteca since June 16, 2008. He served as Redevelopment Director for the City of Stockton, California from 1994 to 2008. He has also worked for the cities of Long Beach and Redondo Beach. Born in Wisconsin, Mr. Pinkerton has a Master’s degree in Urban Planning and and a Master's Degree in Economics from the University of Southern California, and Bachelor’s degrees in Economics and Geography from the University of Missouri.

Wednesday, July 1, 2009

Labor Contracts in the Spotlight

As the state begins the new fiscal year with no budget resolution in sight, many critics of state government are now focusing on labor costs. With the highest public employee salaries in the country, many outside of the legislature are beginning the question the premise that it is programming that should take the brunt of the budget cuts. Many are beginning to argue that public sector salaries and benefits are the main deficit culprit and that our budget problems can be solved if public sector workers begin to take the same compensation hits as their private sector brethren.

While this is certainly an oversimplification at the state level where salaries are a small percentage of the overall budget, it particularly holds true for local government where most budgets are 70-80 percent labor related. It is critical that we at the local government level begin to ensure that our compensation plans begin to mirror the labor market as a whole where both salaries and benefits are taking a major hit.

Here are a couple of articles that demonstrate the groundswell of frustration over public employee compensation. The first is from one of the usual critics of government, the Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Association. While his opinion is not surprising, the fact that this article is being referenced in many mainstream publications demonstrates the sea change in attitude towards public employee compensation. Click here to read.

The second article chronicles the many hidden perks in many public safety labor contracts. This has become a recurring theme in main stream media articles. While there is still a lot of public support for retaining public safety workers, there is beginning to be little or no support for the salaries that police and firefighters are receiving. It notes how a patrol officer was able to get a 47 percent salary increase without any promotion or change in duties via the provisions of her city's labor contract. The article can be accessed by clicking here.

Labels:

2 Comments:

  • At July 2, 2009 6:46 PM , Blogger gale said...

    It takes alot of stones to go after employees salaries when you as the city manager make over 200K a year, have great perks, and good benefits. Let me ask you a question Mr. Pinkerton, what exactly have you given back to help out? You continually hammer your police officers and firefighters for the City's financial problems and you devote numerous blog postings are newspaper articles to the subject. Yet when your firefighters voluntarily re-opened their contract and saved the City over $1 Million dollars, you barely mention it. Have you even moved to Manteca yet as part of your contract called for?

     
  • At July 2, 2009 10:08 PM , Blogger City Manager said...

    Thanks for the comment gale. I'm glad you asked about my contract. All of management staff including myself, will be volutarily giving up at a minumum, the same percentage of our compensation that the other labor groups will be giving back--just as we did in the last round of negotiations that resulted in the furloughs.

    I'm glad you noticed the inordinate number of posts about city budgets and labor contracts. I strongly believe that all of the city's employees need to be aware of what is happening in other cities. Local government finance is undergoing a permanent transition, with far less revenue available in the future. All of us are going to need to work together to ensure that we can still provide top notch service to our community and fairly compensate our employees. I think that news stories from other cities show the many approaches being pursued to balance services and employee compensation. I also want to share the news articles that are probing deeply into our compensation practices. Government employee compensation is on the front burner right now politically and we all need to be aware of that when negotiating contracts.

    Regarding fire reopening their contract, I'm very glad they are willing to talk--and I'd like to do that face to face and not via the blog. I look forward to working with fire to preserve a high level of service for our community.

     

Post a Comment

<< Home